deviant art

Deviant Login Shop
 Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

More from *TehAngelsCry

Featured in Groups:

Details

January 23
Sta.sh Writer
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 42
Favourites: 101 [who?]

Views: 1,195 (1 today)
[x]

How to get more from your commenters!

Journal Entry: Wed Jan 23, 2013, 1:53 PM
If like me you crave critique and feedback, but only ever get "nice work" comments, here are some tips to get what you want!

First of all, allow me to briefly elaborate on what I mean by critique and feedback.

Critique - Noun, A detailed analysis and assessment of something.
Someone who offers you a critique gifts you with a full evaluation of the good and bad parts of your piece, as well as offering ideas for its improvement.

Feedback - NounInformation about reactions to a product.
They let you know which parts they like / don't like, and possibly how the piece made them feel.

Comments such as "Great work!" "Awesome" don't fall into either of these categories.

Reply to them with a question.


Asking a question prompts a response. Not only that, but it forces them to take a look at your work again! Below are two screenshots where I have used this technique.



Common questions you could ask in response to a comment are:
What is your favourite part?
Do you think anything needs improving?
Is the idea behind it clear enough?

When you finally do receive the feedback, be gracious. They are not obliged to give you their opinion of your piece. If you act like a prima donna after receiving a little bit of feedback (which you asked for), then you have a lot of growing up to do. 

Remember to thank them both times for their time as well! A little politeness can go a long way.

My reply to *travelgirlxx sparked a whole string of conversation between us, and she provided me wonderful feedback!

Comment back

They've left you a comment, so why not return the favour? If you find yourself frustrated by their lack of wanted feedback, don't get angry with them, comment on one of their pieces with the same level of detail that you would expect. Basically, give what you want to receive. 

Some example comments could be:
"Perhaps the eyes could be drawn better but the rest of the detail is lovely!"
"I'm not sure that the blurriness of the text adds to this, but it's really well made nonetheless."
"I adore the rhythm of this piece! But it seems to slow down in the middle, is that intentional?"

Always try and point out a part of the piece which really blows you mind. Are the eyes exceptionally beautiful? Is it framed expertly? Are the colours beautifully saturated that it all comes alive? Or quite the opposite, are they soft and calming?


Add a Comment:
 
love 1 1 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconnokia-m97:
~nokia-m97 Apr 7, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
Really good job, it's really interesting :clap:
Reply
:icontehangelscry:
*TehAngelsCry Apr 8, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
Thank you :D I hope it helps you!
Reply
:icontehangelscry:
*TehAngelsCry Feb 9, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
:la: you're awesome! Thank you :)
Reply
:iconnamenotrequired:
$namenotrequired Feb 12, 2013  Student Interface Designer
You're welcome :D
Reply
:iconzmote:
*zmote Feb 3, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Hmm I kinda like the apporach, thanks, I think this way I might get more in contact with commentators...
Reply
:icontehangelscry:
*TehAngelsCry Feb 3, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
Aye that too! I've started developing friendships with a few of my commenter's :D
Reply
:iconafter--life:
~After--Life Jan 27, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
WOW AMAZING! VERY INTELLIGENT!

Faved.

I will do this strategy lol. =D

This is going in my Feedback for Faves too so others can see! ;)
Reply
:icontehangelscry:
*TehAngelsCry Jan 28, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
Sweet! I'm so glad it's help you :la:
Reply
:iconafter--life:
~After--Life Jan 28, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
^__^
Reply
Add a Comment: